How to Get Leads as an AI Agency Founder

How to Get Leads as an AI Agency Founder
Photo by Campaign Creators / Unsplash

Most people starting AI agencies get this backwards. They think they need to master content creation or cold outreach first. They're wrong.

I've watched hundreds of founders burn months on the wrong lead generation strategies. They write elaborate LinkedIn posts that get three likes. They send cold emails that sound like they were written by ChatGPT. They buy courses on Facebook ads before they've made their first dollar.

This is like trying to scale a recipe you've never cooked.

There's a simpler way, but it requires doing something that feels unambitious: starting with people who already know you.

Most founders resist this because it doesn't feel like "real" marketing. Real marketing has funnels and conversion rates and fancy dashboards. Texting your former coworker feels too easy.

But that's exactly why it works.

Think about how trust actually gets built. When someone you know recommends a restaurant, you go. When a stranger hands you a flyer for the same restaurant, you throw it away. The restaurant hasn't changed. The difference is the messenger.

Your warm network is your unfair advantage, especially when you're unknown. These people will take your call. They'll give you honest feedback. They'll tell you when your idea sounds stupid, which is more valuable than a dozen polite rejections from strangers.

Here's what actually happens when you start with warm outreach: You discover what you're really selling.

Most founders think they know what problem they solve. They'll tell you they help restaurants automate their inventory, or they help lawyers process documents faster. But when they start talking to real people, they learn something different.

The restaurant owner doesn't care about automation. He cares about going home before midnight. The lawyer doesn't want faster document processing. She wants to stop working weekends.

You only learn this stuff through conversation. And conversations are easier with people who already trust you.

Cold outreach has the opposite problem. When strangers don't respond to your messages, you don't know why. Maybe your offer is wrong. Maybe your targeting is off. Maybe your subject line sucks. Maybe all three.

With warm outreach, you get real data. When your friend says "I don't think my business needs this," you can ask why. When a former colleague says "This sounds interesting but too expensive," you can explore what would make it worth the cost.

This feedback is gold. You can't get it from analytics dashboards or A/B tests. You have to talk to humans.

The other thing warm outreach gives you is speed. You're not building an audience from scratch or waiting for your content to go viral. You're working with relationships that already exist.

But here's where most people go wrong: they think warm outreach means begging friends for favors. It doesn't. It means having genuine conversations about real problems.

The best warm outreach doesn't feel like outreach at all. It feels like catching up. You're asking questions because you're curious, not because you're trying to sell something.

"Hey, how's the restaurant business these days? I keep hearing about labor shortages."

"How are you handling all the new compliance stuff at the firm?"

Start there. Listen to what people actually say. You'll be surprised how often they mention problems you could solve.

Most founders skip this step because it seems too slow. They want to go from zero to six figures without talking to anyone they know. They think warm outreach doesn't scale.

They're wrong about scaling, but right about it being slow if you do it badly. The goal isn't to squeeze every possible lead out of your personal network. The goal is to figure out what you're really selling, then use that clarity everywhere else.

Once you know who your customers are and what they actually want to pay for, then you can write cold emails that work. Then you can create content that resonates. Then you can run ads that convert.

But trying to do any of that before you have clarity is like navigating without a map. You might eventually find your destination, but you'll waste a lot of time and gas getting there.

There's another benefit to starting warm: it forces you to explain your business in normal words. When you're talking to your brother-in-law or former roommate, you can't hide behind jargon. You have to make sense.

This is harder than it sounds. Most people in tech love complexity. They'll say they're "building AI-powered workflow optimization solutions for mid-market enterprises." When forced to explain this to their mom, they discover they're helping companies process paperwork faster.

The second version is clearer. It's also more likely to get someone to say "Oh, my friend's company has a huge problem with paperwork."

That's how referrals actually work. People can't refer you if they don't understand what you do.

The dirty secret of every successful company is that their first customers came from the founder's network. Google's first users were Stanford students and faculty. Facebook started with Harvard students. Airbnb's first hosts were people the founders knew personally.

This isn't a bug. It's a feature. Starting with people who know and trust you gives you room to be imperfect while you figure things out.

The mistake is thinking you need to graduate from this stage as quickly as possible. You don't. Some of the best companies I know still get most of their customers through referrals, even years later.

Your warm network is not a consolation prize. It's the foundation everything else gets built on.


Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Gareth B. Davies.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.